The Full Picture

The Big Picture · Discussion

The 25 Best Movies of the Century: No. 24 - ‘The Handmaiden’

March 26, 2025/ 38 min/ Sean Fennessey · Amanda Dobbins

Sean Fennessey and Amanda Dobbins put Park Chan-wook's The Handmaiden at No. 24 on their 25-for-25 list, picking it over Oldboy. They cover why: the Sarah Waters adaptation moved from Victorian England to 1930s colonial Korea, the three-act shifting-perspective structure, the argument over whether its sex scenes are exploitative or the film's whole point, its odd Amazon provenance, and where it sits in the Korean New Wave on the road to Parasite. Ends with a recommended-if-you-like slate.

41 films across 1 segment.

AI-generated This episode was transcribed and analyzed with AI models. The matches aren't perfect — expect the occasional misheard title or a link to the wrong film.

No. 24: ‘The Handmaiden’25 for 25

The Handmaiden poster

The Handmaiden 2016

The pick, at No. 24. Park Chan-wook's 2016 thriller, co-written with Chung Seo-kyung, adapting Sarah Waters's 2002 novel Fingersmith but moving it from Victorian England to Korea under 1930s Japanese colonial rule. A Korean conman and an orphaned pickpocket (Kim Tae-ri, in her feature debut) plot to swindle a Japanese heiress, Hideko (Kim Min-hee); the con keeps turning over across three acts told from shifting perspectives. Sean and Amanda say they went back and forth with Oldboy before landing here, calling it the culmination of Park's craft, an erotic thriller of a kind the U.S. abandoned, and probably his best. Much of the talk is the exploitation-vs.-liberation debate over the sex scenes, which they argue are earned by the character's porn-saturated upbringing and by the film's ending, where the two women escape the men entirely.

Oldboy poster

Oldboy 2003

Park's American breakthrough and the Handmaiden's rival for this slot. The hosts grant it's the more historically important film (the hallway fight, the introduction of the Korean New Wave to the U.S.), but say The Handmaiden is the one they actually love.

Parasite poster

Parasite 2019

The conclusive moment of the Korean New Wave, a few years after this; the hosts ask whether The Handmaiden helped clear the American path Parasite eventually took to Best Picture, and decide not quite.

The Age of Shadows poster

The Age of Shadows 2016

Korea's actual 2016 Oscar submission over The Handmaiden. The hosts read the snub as the country steering away from something this sexually explicit. It wasn't nominated.

Snowpiercer poster

Snowpiercer 2013

Cited as the counterexample to The Handmaiden's reach: a Weinstein release with a mostly English-language, American cast, where The Handmaiden was the more widely distributed straight-Korean film.

The Housemaid poster

The Housemaid 1960

Kim Ki-young's 1960 film about a young woman who joins a wealthy household and detonates it from within, made during a brief lifting of Korean censorship. Scorsese and Bong have both championed it; the hosts hear it as the clear ancestor of this movie, down to the title.

Stranger by the Lake poster

Stranger by the Lake 2013

One of the European and Asian erotic thrillers the hosts say kept the genre alive after Hollywood dropped it.

Blue Is the Warmest Color poster

Blue Is the Warmest Color 2013

The comparison point Sean returns to: another film accused of exploitation and unrealistic sex, but gritty and realistic where The Handmaiden is a designed, over-the-top period piece.

Black Book poster

Black Book 2006

Named in the run of lurid-but-classy thrillers Europe and Asia kept making.

The Skin I Live In poster

The Skin I Live In 2011

Another of the persisting erotic thrillers cited, alongside the work of Luca Guadagnino.

M poster

M 1931

Fritz Lang's film, where Sean starts the lineage of the sex-and-power thriller that runs through Hitchcock and lands on Park.

Michael Clayton poster

Michael Clayton 2007

Running gag about what's buried on Amazon Prime Video; Sean keeps needing to note where you can actually stream these movies.

Manchester by the Sea poster

Manchester by the Sea 2016

Part of Amazon's 2016 art-house spree under Ted Hope, the same slate that brought The Handmaiden to U.S. audiences.

Paterson poster

Paterson 2016

Jim Jarmusch's film, another Amazon 2016 pickup and also in that year's Cannes lineup.

Wiener-Dog poster

Wiener-Dog 2016

Todd Solondz's film, cited among the filmmakers Amazon kept working that year.

Love & Friendship poster

Love & Friendship 2016

Whit Stillman's Austen adaptation, which Sean flags as an Amanda favorite, on the same Amazon slate.

The Neon Demon poster

The Neon Demon 2016

Nicolas Winding Refn's film, an Amazon 2016 pickup that also screened at Cannes that year.

Café Society poster

Café Society 2016

Woody Allen's film, rounding out the Amazon 2016 acquisitions the hosts list.

I, Daniel Blake poster

I, Daniel Blake 2016

Ken Loach's Palme d'Or winner at the 2016 Cannes where The Handmaiden played and went home empty, Loach's second Palme.

The Salesman poster

The Salesman 2016

Asghar Farhadi's Best International Feature winner from that same Cannes, his second after A Separation.

A Separation poster

A Separation 2011

Farhadi's earlier foreign-language Oscar winner, the reference point for The Salesman's win.

American Honey poster

American Honey 2016

Named in the rundown of that year's Cannes lineup.

Elle poster

Elle 2016

Paul Verhoeven's Cannes 2016 film, which Amanda calls a perfect double feature with The Handmaiden.

Personal Shopper poster

Personal Shopper 2016

Another title from the 2016 Cannes slate the hosts reel off.

Toni Erdmann poster

Toni Erdmann 2016

Also on the Cannes 2016 list Sean runs through.

Loving poster

Loving 2016

Jeff Nichols's film, the last title in the Cannes 2016 rundown.

Thief poster

Thief 1981

Sean's Michael Mann comparison: through this movie Park was, to him, still pre-Last-of-the-Mohicans Mann, a master of one grounded, grimy thing. Thief is the archetype.

Manhunter poster

Manhunter 1986

Cited alongside Thief as the hard-bitten early-Mann mode Park had been working in until The Handmaiden bumped him up a tier.

The Keep poster

The Keep 1983

The exception Sean flags in early Mann's otherwise grounded run.

The Last of the Mohicans poster

The Last of the Mohicans 1992

The Mann film that marks the leap in Sean's analogy, the point where a filmmaker known for one thing opens up, as Park does here.

Vertigo poster

Vertigo 1958

In the closing recommended-if-you-like slate, and, per Park, the number-one influence on the film. Sean says it changed Park's life.

Rebecca poster

Rebecca 1940

Recommended alongside Vertigo for the Hitchcock strain, with a Mrs. Danvers figure and a house full of illusions.

Gaslight poster

Gaslight 1944

The recommended starting point: the Charles Boyer film that gave the language 'gaslighting,' which the con here runs on.

Diabolique poster

Diabolique 1955

Henri-Georges Clouzot's thriller (Sean says 'Diabolik'), recommended for the twist-driven deception; he notes the bad '90s American remake.

Bound poster

Bound 1996

The Wachowskis' lesbian crime drama, recommended for the obvious throughline.

Wild Things poster

Wild Things 1998

The erotic thriller Amanda pulls as the closest youth-era match, too classy for the Adrian Lyne suburban dramas but just as explicit.

Eyes Wide Shut poster

Eyes Wide Shut 1999

On the recommended slate for the sex-and-power register.

Gone Girl poster

Gone Girl 2014

Recommended for the marriage-as-con machinery, though the hosts note it lacks the film's third-woman geometry.

The Favourite poster

The Favourite 2018

Yorgos Lanthimos's film, the closer on the slate, another European working in this mode as America stopped.

The Town poster

The Town 2010

In the sign-off: the Ben Affleck film Sean would buy tickets to on the Rewatchables Boston screening tour.

Not films filtered out: TV, games, ads

TV Miami ViceThe Handmaid's Tale

Books FingersmithThe Plum in the Golden Vase

Art The Dream of the Fisherman's Wife

Ads Audi Q6 e-tron