The Full Picture

The Big Picture · Discussion · Review · Rankings

Mel at 100: The Mel Brooks Movie Rankings. Plus: ‘Scary Movie’ Is Terrifyingly Awful

June 9, 2026/ 112 min/ Sean Fennessey · Amanda Dobbins

Sean and Amanda open on a fifth straight boom weekend at the box office and a 'Scary Movie' reboot no one in the theater was laughing at, then Yasi Salek and Adam Nayman join to mark Mel Brooks's 100th birthday by ranking all 11 films he directed.

15 films across 3 segments.

AI-generated This episode was transcribed and analyzed with AI models. The matches aren't perfect — expect the occasional misheard title or a link to the wrong film.

The box office boomfive straight weekends of ‘we're back’

Obsession poster

Obsession 2026

Curry Barker's word-of-mouth hit keeps climbing week over week. One industry figure Sean spoke to compared it to Easy Rider. It's on track to outgross Backrooms despite a fraction of the opening.

Backrooms poster

Backrooms 2026

Kane Parsons's $80 million opening rode a built-in fan base, but the general public is cooling on it faster than on Obsession.

Masters of the Universe poster

Masters of the Universe 2026

The He-Man movie made about $30 million, not a disaster on its own but a bomb against its IP and budget.

‘Scary Movie’the reboot at the top of the box office

Scary Movie poster

Scary Movie 2026

A $55 million opening for supposedly dead IP, reuniting most of the original cast: Wayans brothers, Anna Faris, Regina Hall. Both hosts found it painfully unfunny and their audiences barely laughed, but the marketing works: a trailer stacked with references (Sinners, Smile, M3GAN, Longlegs) is enough. Sean's one defense is the livestream scene. The old satirists are now the veterans taking shots at younger filmmakers' work.

The Mel Brooks Movie Rankingswith Yasi Salek and Adam Nayman, on Brooks's 100th birthday · all 11 he directed

Young Frankenstein poster
No. 1

Young Frankenstein 1974

No. 1. The consensus best-made of the 11: camera, lenses, sets, Peter Boyle's monster. Sean and Adam's pick; Amanda grants it's the finest achievement even if Blazing Saddles is her favorite.

Blazing Saddles poster
No. 2

Blazing Saddles 1974

No. 2. The most important one, and the one older listeners name first. Richard Pryor in the writers' room, Madeline Kahn's Dietrich number; still bracing enough that Adam wants to screen it just to see what a room does with it.

The Producers poster
No. 3

The Producers 1967

No. 3. The Oscar-winning script and his one fully original idea. More polished than anyone remembered; Springtime for Hitler lands harder for arriving 20 years after the war.

Spaceballs poster
No. 4

Spaceballs 1987

No. 4. The most beloved, made because his kids wore out the Star Wars tapes. Bill Pullman doing Harrison Ford, Rick Moranis's Dark Helmet; Sean finds it over-reliant on its source.

History of the World, Part I poster
No. 5

History of the World, Part I 1981

No. 5. The anthology format saves it: a weak sketch is only ten minutes from a good one. The Spanish Inquisition musical and the Viking funeral are the keepers.

Robin Hood: Men in Tights poster
No. 6

Robin Hood: Men in Tights 1993

No. 6, on sentiment. Cary Elwes spoofing his own Princess Bride shtick, Dave Chappelle at 19; the contemporary gags have a short shelf life.

The Twelve Chairs poster
No. 7

The Twelve Chairs 1970

No. 7. The forgotten one, a 1928 Russian novel turned Bolshevik buddy comedy. Frank Langella pre-Dracula; Yasi's soft spot, and the ending got her.

High Anxiety poster
No. 8

High Anxiety 1977

No. 8. The Hitchcock homage, too reverent and too close to work: Hitch was already funny. Best when Brooks drops the parody and just sings the title song.

Silent Movie poster
No. 9

Silent Movie 1976

No. 9. A blank-check tribute to silent cinema that cuts him off from his best tool, his voice. The Marcel Marceau gag is the highlight and the indictment.

Life Stinks poster
No. 10

Life Stinks 1991

No. 10. The outlier: a sincere rich-man-goes-broke story, not a parody. Yasi defends it as a masterpiece; the others won't push it past 10.

Dracula: Dead and Loving It poster
No. 11

Dracula: Dead and Loving It 1995

No. 11, dead last, unanimous. Cheaply made, and Leslie Nielsen's magic didn't survive the trip from the ZAZ team to Brooks.

Also mentioned raised along the way

In the box-office talk Iron LungThe Devil Wears Prada 2Project Hail MaryThe OdysseyToy Story 5SupergirlSpider-Man: Brand New DayMoanaHereditaryEasy RiderBonnie and Clyde

Horror the new ‘Scary Movie’ spoofs ScreamGet OutM3GANHalloweenSmileLonglegsSinnersKPop Demon Hunters

Named in the Brooks conversation To Be or Not to BeThe Elephant ManThe FlyFrancesEraserheadJojo Rabbit2001: A Space OdysseyStar WarsThe Mandalorian and GroguTrading PlacesBrewster's MillionsThe Hudsucker ProxyPennies from HeavenDirty Rotten ScoundrelsThe Adventures of Robin HoodRobin Hood: Prince of ThievesRobin HoodThe Princess BrideAirplane!Top Secret!The Naked GunPolice AcademyBasic InstinctSpy HardRepossessedPlaytimeThe ArtistLove and DeathBoogie NightsHome AloneReality Bites

Not films filtered out: TV, games, ads

TV Get SmartYour Show of ShowsThe SimpsonsSeinfeld30 RockParks and RecreationFamily GuyGame of ThronesThe MandalorianHistory of the World, Part IIAlly McBealThe Singing Detective

Web series The Amazing Digital Circus

Ads State FarmPepsi