The Full Picture

The Big Picture · Discussion · Rankings

Dune. DUNE. DUNE!

October 25, 2021/ 74 min/ Sean Fennessey · Amanda Dobbins · Chris Ryan

Sean, Amanda, and Chris Ryan spend an hour on Denis Villeneuve's Dune — the spectacle, the mid-movie downshift, the unmarked part-one problem, the box office — then rank Villeneuve's filmography and fight about where Enemy belongs.

10 films across 2 segments.

AI-generated This episode was transcribed and analyzed with AI models. The matches aren't perfect — expect the occasional misheard title or a link to the wrong film.

DuneSean and Amanda with Chris Ryan

Dune poster

Dune 2021

The main text. Amanda's mind was blown for the first hour, then wandered; all three agree the last 45 minutes downshift into a mother-son picnic. Chris's read: it doesn't insult the audience. Debated at length — Zimmer's percussive-choral score, Greg Fraser's photography, the ornithopters and sandworms, the gun-free hand-to-hand combat, the fact that the theatrical print didn't label itself 'Part One,' and the near-certain sequel. $40M domestic, north of $220M worldwide, likely a lock for the below-the-line Oscars.

Dune poster

Dune 1984

David Lynch's version, which Sean and Amanda rewatched — compresses two books into 2h15m, a mistake Lynch essentially disowned; its 1984 sandworms hold up better than expected.

Jodorowsky's Dune poster

Jodorowsky's Dune 2013

The documentary on Alejandro Jodorowsky's unmade 1970s adaptation; Sean floats Jodorowsky as the filmmaker better suited to the book's 'space acid' register that Villeneuve avoids.

The Villeneuve Rankingsthe brokered top seven

Sicario poster
No. 1

Sicario 2015

No. 1 — where Sean and Chris meet; Sean holds it as the best. 'Sicario means hitman.'

Arrival poster
No. 2

Arrival 2016

No. 2 and Amanda's No. 1; the hopeful one, the movie she's championed on the show for years.

Dune poster
No. 3

Dune 2021

No. 3, everyone 'high off the spice.' Chris slotted it here fresh out of the theater.

Blade Runner 2049 poster
No. 4

Blade Runner 2049 2017

No. 4; Chris thinks it gets mired in its own navel-gazing, Amanda rates it above Prisoners.

Prisoners poster
No. 5

Prisoners 2013

No. 5, the compromise slot. Shot by Deakins, which the group agrees is the only thing keeping it from being 'banned from society.'

Incendies poster
No. 6

Incendies 2010

No. 6; his English-language-adjacent breakthrough for American audiences, adapted from a play, with a traumatic ending.

Enemy poster
No. 7

Enemy 2013

No. 7 — 'just shameful,' per Sean, who wanted it at No. 3. Opens on the title card 'chaos is order yet undeciphered.'

Also mentioned raised along the way

The sci-fi lineage Star WarsThe MatrixBlade RunnerAlien2001: A Space Odyssey

Touchstones in the conversation Apocalypse NowBraveheartEasy RiderRogue One: A Star Wars StoryZero Dark ThirtyTenetMichael Clayton

The cast, elsewhere Assassin's CreedRed SparrowDoctor SleepReminiscenceThe Greatest ShowmanMen in Black: InternationalThe Card Counter

The 2021 Oscar field The Power of the DogBelfastKing RichardWest Side StoryNightmare AlleyThe Tragedy of MacbethLicorice PizzaHouse of GucciThe Last DuelEternals

In passing ZodiacThe Social NetworkNo Country for Old MenRangoThe Ballad of Buster ScruggsThe AvengersStar Trek Into DarknessSpider-Man 3The Dark KnightThe Ten CommandmentsBen-HurLast Night in Soho

Not films filtered out: TV, games, ads

TV The ExpanseFoundationSuccessionInsecureThe SopranosSex and the CityLostDune: The SisterhoodDune (2000 miniseries)

Podcasts Serial

Ads Netflix FIFA World Cup Launch EditionBoar's HeadNOS EnergySpotify