The Full Picture

The Big Picture · Interview · Rankings

'Asteroid City' and the Wes Anderson Movie Rankings

June 20, 2023/ 84 min/ Sean Fennessey · Amanda Dobbins

Sean Fennessey and Amanda Dobbins are joined by critic Adam Naiman to talk through 'Asteroid City,' then rank all 11 Wes Anderson features. Amanda wins the argument by planting 'The Royal Tenenbaums' at No. 1.

12 films across 2 segments.

AI-generated This episode was transcribed and analyzed with AI models. The matches aren't perfect — expect the occasional misheard title or a link to the wrong film.

'Asteroid City'the 11th Wes Anderson feature

Asteroid City poster
With Adam Naiman on

Asteroid City 2023

A black-and-white TV documentary about the staging of a play, whose color film-within is set in a 1955 desert town during a Junior Stargazer convention interrupted by an alien; Jason Schwartzman and Scarlett Johansson lead a cast that runs from Tom Hanks to Jeff Goldblum. Sean was moved and calls it a bold experiment he hasn't fully locked into; Amanda read it as a synthesis and a 'summit'; Adam admired the engineering but felt the emotions were engineered too, and parked it in Anderson's 'vast accomplished middle.'

The Wes Anderson Movie Rankingsbest to worst

The Royal Tenenbaums poster
No. 1

The Royal Tenenbaums 2001

Amanda's hard-won No. 1: 'quintessential,' the Gene Hackman performance maybe the best in any of his films. Hackman and Anderson famously didn't get along, which Sean argues is exactly why it works.

Rushmore poster
No. 2

Rushmore 1998

Sean's touchstone and 'the last time he was emotionally dangerous'; the movie that changed his moviegoing at 17.

Moonrise Kingdom poster
No. 3

Moonrise Kingdom 2012

Sean calls it a perfect movie and the end of Anderson's middle period; producer Bobby Wagner named it a co-favorite with Grand Budapest.

Asteroid City poster
No. 4

Asteroid City 2023

Slotted at No. 4 after a fight; both reserve the right to move it, and Amanda argues it's more emotionally impactful than the film below it.

The Grand Budapest Hotel poster
No. 5

The Grand Budapest Hotel 2014

'Maybe the best made of all of his movies' and his biggest commercial hit; Ralph Fiennes' performance 'sort of invented millennial pink.' Amanda ceded it to five, though she rates it far higher.

Fantastic Mr. Fox poster
No. 6

Fantastic Mr. Fox 2009

The stop-motion film both love but keep just outside the top five; a fascinating innovation and his most dollhouse-like to that point.

Bottle Rocket poster
No. 8

Bottle Rocket 1996

Adam (and Steely Dan) rate it near the top; Sean docks it for a supporting cast that can't keep up with Owen Wilson.

The French Dispatch poster
No. 9

The French Dispatch 2021

Dense and cerebral without the emotional payoff of the best; Sean expects it to grow on rewatch the way it did for him after Telluride.

The Darjeeling Limited poster
No. 10

The Darjeeling Limited 2007

The consensus low: improved over time but still 'deeply flawed'; Sean thinks its perceived failure pushed Anderson into his current phase.

Isle of Dogs poster
No. 11

Isle of Dogs 2018

Least essential for both; feels redundant after Fantastic Mr. Fox, though the sushi scene is glorious.

Also mentioned raised along the way

In the 'Asteroid City' conversation OppenheimerTenetThe SearchersThe Man Who Wasn't ThereMagic Mike's Last DancePriscillaThere Will Be BloodNo Country for Old MenA Streetcar Named DesireReality BitesLittle Murders

Wes Anderson shorts, left off the list The Wonderful Story of Henry SugarHotel Chevalier

The box-office postscript The FlashElementalTurning RedThe Super Mario Bros. MovieSpider-Man: Across the Spider-VersePast LivesNo Hard FeelingsAmourWitnessThe Marvels

Not films filtered out: TV, games, ads

TV / sketches The Twilight ZoneThe Midnight Coterie of Sinister Intruders

Podcasts The RewatchablesPrestige TV

Ads FanDuelCarvanaMint MobileWhole FoodsNOS EnergyTalkAboutPD